Great New York Pizza Menu (Updated 2026)

View photos

Menu-1

Menu-2

Menu-3

Menu-4

Menu-5

Welcome to Great New York Pizza, a hidden gem located at 308 Pine St, Nicollet, MN. This quaint pizzeria is celebrated for its homemade, hand-tossed pizzas that have left locals raving. With offerings like the NY Supreme and mesmerizing gyro pizza, each dish promises a delightful burst of flavor thanks to generous fresh toppings and a golden crust.

The menu doesn’t stop at pizza; indulge in hearty pasta dishes paired with garlic bread and satisfying 7" sandwiches, including classics like the Philly Steak and Buffalo Chicken Ranch.

Reviewers admire the swift, friendly service and the clean ambiance. Whether you dine-in, take-out, or enjoy local delivery, Great New York Pizza offers a delicious, affordable feast perfect for any occasion. Come experience why it's quickly becoming a favorite in Nicollet!

The menu focuses heavily on classic Italian dishes, with pasta options such as Ziti, Lasagna, and Spaghetti offered alongside garlic bread. Side dishes and salads provide lighter or complementary choices, including Roasted Red Potatoes, Chips, and various fresh salads like Garden, Caesar, and Greek. Pricing is accessible, ranging from $1 to $10, indicating most items are budget-friendly with no distinct premium segment. The variety suggests suitability for lunch or casual dinner occasions where straightforward, affordable meals are preferred. The absence of breakfast-specific items aligns the menu primarily with midday and evening dining.

More Pizza restaurants Menus in Minnesota

Explore Pizza restaurants Menus

Papa Tronnio's Pizza

Papa Tronnio's Pizza

218 2nd St W, Wabasha, MN 55981, United States

4.5 42 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Luigi's Pizza

Luigi's Pizza

122 4th St NE, East Grand Forks, MN 56721, United States

4.5 54 Ratings
$1–10

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Italian Pie Shoppe

Italian Pie Shoppe

7107 N 42nd Ave, New Hope, MN 55427, United States

4.4 96 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Browse Menus Across Minnesota

Shaws Bar & Grill

Shaws Bar & Grill

1528 University Ave NE, Minneapolis, MN 55413, United States

4.5 602 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Sullivan Candy and Supply, Inc.

Sullivan Candy and Supply, Inc.

1206 E 25th St, Hibbing, MN 55746, United States

3.9 32 Ratings

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Continental Restaurant LLC

Continental Restaurant LLC

1040 Osborne Rd NE, Fridley, MN 55432, United States

4 23 Ratings
₫₫

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

The Blends Chaska

The Blends Chaska

108 Pioneer Trail, Chaska, MN 55318, United States

4.4 33 Ratings
$1–10

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Munger Tavern & Grill

Munger Tavern & Grill

4003 Munger Shaw Rd, Cloquet, MN 55720, United States

4.3 91 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Red Truck Ice Cream

Red Truck Ice Cream

113 Main St, Cold Spring, MN 56320, United States

4.8 84 Ratings

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Old Mill Bar & Restaurant

Old Mill Bar & Restaurant

90 Main St, Parkers Prairie, MN 56361, United States

4.6 252 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Mickey's Diner

Mickey's Diner

36 7th St W, St Paul, MN 55102, United States

4.2 2633 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Biff's Kitchen

Biff's Kitchen

811 Atlantic Ave, Thief River Falls, MN 56701, United States

4.4 553 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Firehouse Coffee Company & Salon 227

Firehouse Coffee Company & Salon 227

202 Washburne Ave, Paynesville, MN 56362, United States

4.7 98 Ratings

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Get Fresh Menu Updates

Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.

© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.

Terms of Service
Privacy Policy